Chess: Hans Niemann responds to St Louis ‘dishonest’ controversy | Magnus Carlsen

Magnus Carlsen’s shock withdrawal from the $350,000 Sinquefield Cup in St Louis following his third-round loss to newcomer Hans Niemann sparked quite a lot of “dishonest” allegations. It is doubtlessly essentially the most severe case for worldwide chess because the 2005 Toiletgate World Championship match, when Veselin Topalov accused Vlad Kramnik of analyzing video games in the bathroom.

Carlsen’s loss to 19-year-old Niemann was his first in a number of years with White towards a a lot lower-rated opponent, and it was the Norwegian’s first profession withdrawal. His solely rationalization was a cryptic video clip of soccer supervisor Jose Morinho saying ‘If I discuss, I am in huge hassle’, throughout a referee press convention.

This was broadly interpreted as elevating suspicions of dishonest. Safety was tightened, the fourth-round broadcast was delayed for quarter-hour, and Niemann was completely searched earlier than his match began, however nothing was discovered.

Main chess streamer GM Hikaru Nakamura has weighed in with the revelation that, a few years earlier, Niemann had been briefly banned by Chess.com for pc use in a web-based event. Carlsen’s opening 1 d4 Nf6 2 c4 e6 3 Nc3 Bb4 4 g3, had been ready by Niemann intimately.

The Californian teenager, who has no coach however whose score has jumped 250 factors in three years, had already crushed the world champion a month earlier in a web-based event in Miami, when he paid the column for a one-sentence victory interview the place he mentioned, “Chess speaks for itself”, earlier than strolling away. For a time in St Louis, he grew to become an outcast.

Then a response set in. The opening exit place was virtually equal, a minimal of 0.3 extra for black, however the world champion gave the impression to be attempting too arduous, with suboptimal picks at strikes 22, 40 and 42. Niemann additionally made inaccuracies. , then the game did not have the telltale indicators of pc assist.

Assist for {the teenager} got here from Jacob Aagaard, the Danish-Scottish grandmaster who was British champion in 2007 and is a popular author. Frenchman Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, who competes in St Louis, mentioned: “The scandal has turn out to be a witch hunt.”

Then Niemann spoke up in his personal protection, throughout his fifth-round post-match interview following his draw with Leinier Domínguez during which his opponent let him slip away in a misplaced place. iIn half an hour of fast dialog (a transcript of the highlights is obtainable about chess24) he addressed the problems towards him and posted a defiant message: “I am not going to let Chess.com, I am not going to let Magnus Carlsen, I am not going to let Hikaru Nakamura, the three arguably best entities in chess, merely slander my fame as a result of the query is, why are they going to take away me from Chess.com proper after I beat Magnus?

Chess 3822
3822: Magnus Carlsen vs Alexey Shirov, Aerosvit, Ukraine 2008. White strikes and wins. How did the then 17-year-old earn this seemingly drawn place?

He was banned from the most important chess website and never invited to the Chess.com World Championship, a $1 million occasion with on-line qualifiers and an eight-player closing in Toronto.

Following this interview, the massive quantity of feedback on-line that had been round 90% towards him dropped to round 60-40 in his favour. There are actually rising requires Carlsen to launch a fuller assertion.

It could appear that the central query is whether or not Carlsen believes that his pre-match evaluation of his predicted upset 1 d4 Nf6 2 c4 e6 3 Nc3 Bb4 4 g3 was leaked, both by a mole in his facet or by a hack.

One other rationalization for the “leak” could possibly be fairly harmless. The related pawn construction, with believable transpositions in Carlsen vs. Niemann, had already occurred in a earlier well-known Carlsen game towards the Englishman Michael Adams in 2006. Niemann mentioned he puzzled what concepts Carlsen might produce to divert him from his Catalan challenge with … Bb4+ and determined to verify 5 Nc3, a uncommon transposition to Nimzo-Indian. There was additionally Niemann’s very current match towards Le Quang Liem in Miami, the place 5 g3 (as an alternative of 5 e3 d5 as performed) d5 6 a3 might simply translate to Carlsen towards Niemann.

Carlsen had began properly in St Louis, beating his 2021 title challenger Ian Nepomniachtchi within the first spherical by means of a Carlsen brand grind of a seemingly even opening, and taking their tally towards their rival to 6 factors of their final seven encounters.

The third spherical on Sunday modified every part and it’s simple to grasp why the world champion was so upset. Carlsen’s event rating will likely be vacated, however his matches will likely be scored and the loss to Niemann will price him seven rating factors, a giant setback in an try to maneuver from 2865 to 2900. His dream of a rating report simply obtained additional away.

In the meantime, Niemann is the one underdog, the brand new child on the block difficult the massive battalions. Older American chess followers, who’ve longed because the Seventies for a second coming of Bobby Fischer, will sympathize with him. Then the institution was Mikhail Botvinnik, Tigran Petrosian and the Soviet Chess Empire. Now it is Carlsen, Nakamura and Chess.com.

After all, the comparability simply breaks down. At 19, Fischer had simply gained the interzonal in Stockholm in 1962 and was the favourite of the Candidates. Niemann at 19, regardless of his meteoric rise, has simply crushed 2700 and continues to be ranked fortieth on the earth. Hans has the Fischer gaze and the ambition to be No. 1, however his mystique is usually primarily based on a single sport towards the world champion.

3832: 1Kg3! Bc3 2 Bg6+ Kg5 3 h4+! gxh3 ep 4 f4 mate. Different solutions price Black not less than his bishop.

Leave a Comment