Jeff Probst Says Survivor’s Controversial Hourglass Twist Is No Extra

Season 40 of Survivor was the tip of an period. With 20 former champions, the War Slice Winners was a celebration of 20 years of outmaneuvering, overcoming and surviving – full with a champagne toast to kick issues off and a document $2 million prize to winner Tony Vlachos.

When the present lastly returned to the air within the fall of 2021 after a Covid-delayed 16-month hiatus, it was billed as the beginning of a New period, with adjustments that prolonged past the abbreviation 26 day format and much more diverse cast. The producers threw the proverbial kitchen sink on the contestants with twist upon twist to maintain gamers consistently on their toes. (Apparently there was additionally some form of “monster” on the unfastened, however that is neither right here nor there.)

Jeff Probst already said EW in May that most of the new wrinkles we noticed on seasons 41 and 42 of Survivor (which have been filmed again to again) could be again for Survivor 43. “Issues like small tribes, win fusion, no meals, threat/reward dilemmas, Shot within the Darkish, are right here to remain,” the host mentioned then. “Different particular twists will come and go relying on the season.”

Survivor 43 Jeff Probst

Survivor 43 Jeff Probst

Robert Voets/CBS Jeff Probst, host of “Survivor”

We now know of two such twists that not be in play for the upcoming season (which is able to begin on September 21 on SCS). After we requested Probst what twists would make a return look, he form of knocked us round. “An attention-grabbing approach to ask this query”, replies the host. “I’ll counter this. This is what you will not see in Survivor 43: Change historical past and do or die. How do you want these apples?”

Earlier than persevering with, a brief refresher course. Altering historical past, or the hourglass twist (because it’s generally recognized) was a brand new wrinkle that to name it extremely controversial could be an understatement. As first offered on Survivor 41, all however two of the gamers simply earlier than the merge have been cut up into two groups to compete in a problem, with the profitable crew routinely receiving immunity for the subsequent Tribal Council, giving them a fast passage by the merge. The losers must take part in a person immunity problem and certainly one of them would then be eradicated.

It is truly fairly an attention-grabbing new ingredient so as to add to a present in its forty first season. However that wasn’t the tip. The profitable crew then acquired to decide on one of many two gamers who didn’t compete to affix them on the profitable facet. On Survivor 41, they selected Naseer Muttalif. This left an Erika Casupanan (beneath, who was additionally now prone to rejection) to be deported to Exile Island on her personal. Nobody knew that Erika was about to be granted the ability to “make historical past by altering historical past”.

It is because Erika was given an hourglass and a hammer, and if she selected to smash it, it will reverse the result of the problem – which means those that gained now risked being eradicated, and those that misplaced (together with together with Erika) have been now fully protected. Erika’s choice was, in reality, no choice in any respect, and she or he not solely broke the hourglass, however ended up win the game.



Robert Voets/CBS Erika Casupanan and Jeff Probst in “Survivor 41”

There was an enormous outcry over the twist, and never simply from viewers, however avid gamers as effectively. “It is not even a twist, it is a lie” Sydney Segal told EW, who was a part of the profitable crew however was nonetheless eradicated. “We’re informed one factor after which one thing else occurs.”

Danny McCray even defined on to the host how unfair the twist was. “We’re rivals” Danny told EW. “Lots of us depart quite a lot of issues at residence to return right here and play this sport. And we put so much on the road and there is an essence to competitors. You play to win so you’ll be able to win one thing, n “Is not it? That is the one motive you’d go there to compete. And the truth that he was capable of lie for us, to lure us and make us work as exhausting as we did simply to have it taken away from us, that simply wasn’t cool with me. And his reply, you recognize, was what it was. I will not actually go into particulars, however I did not prefer it. So I did not prefer it.”

In fact, Danny additionally mentioned in that very same interview that “My actuality TV days could also be over as a result of it was a really, very troublesome state of affairs for me to take care of and take care of,” however he now stars in The Problem: United Statesso it could not be too horrible.

Maybe making an allowance for Danny’s feedback, the present introduced again the controversial twist for Survivor 42, however with a couple of minor adjustments. This time, Probst knowledgeable the winners that the participant they selected to fireside (who ended up being Rocksroy Bailey, beneath) would have the ability to vary the sport, in order that they weren’t fully caught off guard by what was to return. He additionally knowledgeable the winners that certainly one of them might select to commerce locations and forgo the social gathering (and potential immunity, so far as they know) to go to the Exile Island to get this energy. Whereas these have been actually enhancements, they did not get across the basic subject that many had with gamers being punished for competing and profitable one thing.



Robert Voets/CBS Jeff Probst and Rocks Roy Bailey in “Survivor 42”

The Do or Die twist additionally appeared in each seasons and mainly gave gamers the choice to compete or not compete in a problem. In the event that they have been absent, that they had no immunity, but when they competed and have been the primary individual out, they must play a sport of probability which, in the event that they misplaced, would remove them from the sport.

Deshawn Radden and Lindsay Dolashewich have been the primary to participate on this problem for every of their seasons and have been compelled to play the Do or Die sport through which that they had to decide on which field out of three would defend them. Apparently, neither adopted the mathematically advantageous technique that claims it is best to change squares after the primary was revealed, however each ended up beating the chances and being protected.

It appeared like everybody had an opinion on twists, together with yours. Whereas I actually preferred the choice to have gamers take part within the merge, the Hourglass a part of this twist felt gimmicky and patently unfair – one thing accomplished extra for shock worth than strong sport mechanics.

However personally, I had no drawback with the Do or Die twist as a result of, not like the hourglass, all gamers obtained all the principles beforehand and due to this fact might make their choice accordingly. I simply do not perceive why anybody would select to play it. (My solely actual gripe with Do or Die was that you would decide the result of the field sport based mostly on how a lot time was left within the episode. If there was an excessive amount of time left, it was apparent the individual had gained, and they’d once more to do a full tribe vote. Then once more, I am in all probability the one one silly sufficient to match the clock to the episode in actual time.)

Gallery Survivor 43

Gallery Survivor 43

Robert Voets/CBS The solid of ‘Survivor’ 43

Jeff Probst would not stay in a bubble – besides, I assume, the Covid bubble they put in place for filming – so he is heard all of the chatter on-line about controversial plot twists, and he is aware of to take them out of the combo will even elicit a terrific response. “I can already hear some followers celebrating and others saying that we gave in to criticism!” mentioned the host. “We love the fan suggestions, and the edit historical past suggestions was superb. Individuals actually beloved it or actually hated it, however not a single individual mentioned ‘Hey, I can take it or depart it. .’ And with Do or Die, the drama was electrifying, however we additionally thought it was a twist we might placed on the shelf…for now.”

It is very important keep in mind this as a result of Survivor films back-to-back seasons, they weren’t capable of think about fan response after they purchased each the Hourglass and Do or Die twists for season 42. However now they’ve heard Survivor Nation loud and clear, and responded in variety. Until, after all, they’ve an hourglass useful and wish to make historical past by altering historical past once more.

Register for Weekly entertainmentthe free daily newsletter of to get the most recent TV information, unique first appears, recaps, critiques, interviews together with your favourite stars, and extra.

Associated content material:

Leave a Comment